It's ALL hate speech
Nobody could be happier than I that Ann Coulter is finally being shunned by the establishment, right wing and otherwise, after her use of a homophobic epithet for John Edwards at a recent conservative conference. But I'm seeing the fallout, and all I can think is IT'S ABOUT FUCKING TIME. The more I think about it the more I wonder, why was THIS the straw that broke the camel's back? I get that the thing she said is horrible, unacceptable but it's not like Ann's been playing nice for the last few years until she just let slip an untouchable word. (One that she believes is just a "schoolyard taunt." What the hell school did she go to, and since when are schoolyard taunts acceptable political discourse for a woman in her 40's?) Coulter has been spewing vile hate speech in all directions for as long as anyone can remember.
Let's recap just the biggest hit examples of the shameful vitriol that's been flying out of Ann's mouth and off her keyboard for years:
* She said after 9/11 that we should "invade [the hijackers'] countries, kill their leaders and convert them to Christianity."
* She mischaracterized Vietnam veteran and former Georgia Senator Max Cleland's loss of three of his limbs as resulting from him "dropping a grenade on himself," when actually he saved the lives of several soldiers in picking up a grenade that another soldier dropped during a combat mission.
* She suggested that Congressman John Murtha is "the reason soldiers invented fragging," the practice of intentionally shooting a member of one's own unit, as a result of Murtha's advocating that American troops be redirected out of Iraq.
* She accused former Michigan Congressman John Bonior of "fronting for Arab terrorists." That one's a new one!
* She suggested that President Clinton should have been assassinated.
* She suggested former Rhode Island Senator Lincoln Chafee should have been shot.
* She accused the New York Times of treason that "could have gotten them executed." (She has called or more than one occasion for the execution or bombing of the New York Times' editors and staff.)
* She stated that not only did she believe that both Bill and Hillary Clinton might be gay, but also that Al Gore is a "total f*g."
* She said that without affirmative action, California Congresswoman Maxine Waters, who is black, couldn't have a job "that didn't involve wearing a paper hat."
* She said about the widows of men who died on 9/11 "I've never seen people enjoying their husbands' deaths so much."
* She wished the American military were targeting journalists.
* She suggested someone "beat [her] to the punch" and poisoned Supreme Court Justice Stevens.
* She called Islam a "car-burning cult."
And those are just the ones I found before I got tired of looking!
Apparently all of that stuff was just fine with the many sponsors of her website, the newspapers that run her columns, and the many so-called "news organizations" that give her a mouthpiece to spew her crap to the masses. (I'm not even going to get into her publishers or those who buy her books because that is clearly a machine that's all about outrageousness=sales $.) But now suddenly, after she made a "little joke" about Edwards that included an epithet for a homosexual beginning with the letter F that I will not be repeating here (because to me it is every bit as vile as the N word), Coulter has been denounced by all the major Republican candidates, had her column dropped by at least one newspaper, lost multiple advertisers to her website including Verizon, Sallie Mae, and Netbank (good for them! Except why the fuck were they advertising with her in the first place?!), and been denounced by half of the right wing blogosphere and many other right wing pundits (though the jackasses at Fox News Channel continue to stick up for her.)
Why did it take all of these people so long? She used basically a shorter version of the same word to describe Al Gore over a year ago and nobody gave a damn. Hell, Chris Matthews responded just moments later that they'd love to have Ann back on. She has suggested that multiple elected officials, public servants and members of the press deserve to be killed. She has used hate speech directed at racial minorities, other religions, and gays and lesbians. She has suggested that entire countries filled with people should be wiped off the map, tortured or converted to Christianity for the sins of their leaders or the sins of a select few of their countrymen. Ann Coulter has been off the reservation for a long, long time and so pardon me if I can't take much joy in the rest of the right wing finally turning on her when politically expedient even as they've been listening to this crap and taking it in stride for years now.
9 comments:
You have 9 tags under the heading Asshole and on one you call the President of the United States, "Fuckface".
You and Ann are the same person -- just tackling it from a different angle
ARBY
Please tell me you're not serious.
I didn't use a racist, sexist or homophobic slur against the President or anyone else. Nor would I, ever, because I'm not a racist, sexist or homophobe.
I also didn't call for anyone to be killed, tortured or converted to Christianity. Calling someone an asshole or fuckface or a douchebag or any other curse word is simply not hate speech. To imply that they are equivalent is completely disingenous.
Oh, and in case it wasn't clear, I'm also not a nationally syndicated columnist paid to write a column that's featured in hundreds of newspapers and to appear on countless news talk shows to spill my hate out to millions of people. I'm not trying to be, either. Nobody is endorsing my statements or conduct, through monetary support or otherwise.
But thanks for completely missing the point and defending a horrible person for no apparent reason.
No you have missed the point -- perhaps sucking too much wine tonight? I never said anything to defend Ann. You ASSUMED that I did simply because I called your reprehensible conduct into question. Ann's comments are unacceptable -- and so are yours.
You are choosing to use lawyer tricks to define unacceptable hate language only in the context of racist, sexist or homophobic words. Your narrow defintion...oh so carefully...excuses your caustic, inmature, hatefilled venom, and I assumed, liquor fueled rants.
Oh... and the size of the audience is more legal dust. Your blog can be googled. And so can "Fuckface" Your language and hate filled sputum is unacceptable.
I'm still at work, jackass. But the fact that you a) don't understand the meaning of hate speech and b) presume that I'm drunk is pretty much all anyone needs to know to disregard your criticisms as so much psychotic drivel.
And after that little demonstration of defamation, I have one message for you: Post here ever again and it will be deleted. Don't fuck with me, pal.
I hate it when people say things like, "Don't use lawyer tricks on me!" Your argument sucks and it doesn't take a lawyer to dissect it.
Has anyone taken to task the members of that CPAC audience that laughed at her comment? Or has CPAC itself made a statement about the Coulter thing?
Yes, the ACU, organizer of CPAC, issued a statement that was kind of wishy washy but ultimately said they did not "condone or endorse the use of hate speech."
As for taking the audience members who laughed to task, I don't know that there is really a way to do that. Let's be honest, there were probably a decent fraction of that particular audience who see no problem with the use of the word he chose, who think that gays and lesbians are an abomination that deserve to be treated with scorn and contempt and nothing more, and who think what Ann said shouldn't be creating such an uproar.
Wishy-washy indeed. We'll see if she is invited back.
A large part of me thinks Coulter's provocations are only tactics to keep her in the spotlight. Words are just mutable labels; ignore her and she loses power.
Words are just mutable labels; ignore her and she loses power.
Tell that to Sharyar Aziz, who was in town as part of Yale's Baker's Dozen acapella chior tour winter tour now has his jaw wired shut.
He was attacked by a group of San Francisco teen thugs who used the epithet.
Words can hurt, words can kill. We in the African-American community and the GLBT one know that all too well.
Post a Comment